TY - JOUR
T1 - A critical assessment of the Mineral County Challenge
T2 - The role and implications of scale in collaborative development
AU - Nygaard, Kimiko
AU - Bosak, Keith
N1 - Funding Information:
The authors would like to thank the USDA McIntire Stennis Program , the UM College of Forestry and Conservation , the One Montana Initiative for funding this project. We would also like to acknowledge the people in Mineral County who allowed us to take their time and utilize their experiences to hopefully refine the MCC process in order to benefit other counties in the future, including the MSU Extension Office, Dunrovin Research and Ranch, and the many folks and residents in Mineral County that gave their time to speak with us.
PY - 2014/4
Y1 - 2014/4
N2 - In the rural American West, a region rich in natural resources and scenic amenities yet increasingly experiencing rapid demographic and economic shifts, place-based collaboration is endorsed as a means to find mutual resolutions to issues such as land use disputes, natural resource management, and socioeconomic development. However, assessing place-based collaborative models in view of their results is challenging due to differing criteria, expectations, and motivations supporting the collaborative partnership framework. This research uses the case study of Montana's Mineral County Challenge, a rural place-based collaborative development project, to make critical inquiries into the long-term efficacy of such approaches. Given that place-based collaborative projects are grounded in geographical traditions, the focus of this assessment is on the role and implications of scale in determining the trajectory of the collaborative process. This is accomplished by evaluating the Mineral County Challenge to (1) recognize the material and non-material outcomes of collaborative development models and, (2) examine the implications and role of scale in catalyzing or hindering the deliberation and realization of these collaborative endeavors. In doing so, the authors emphasize the spatial and temporal constraints including lack of accountability, administrative formalities, and other institutional intricacies which evolved at the federal level to reduce the overall capacity for local and state-level stakeholders to execute long-term project deliverables. In overcoming these barriers, scale must be reconfigured to account for the conflicting conceptual and operational discrepancies that manifest at different levels of stakeholder exchange to derail and disempower place-based collaboration.
AB - In the rural American West, a region rich in natural resources and scenic amenities yet increasingly experiencing rapid demographic and economic shifts, place-based collaboration is endorsed as a means to find mutual resolutions to issues such as land use disputes, natural resource management, and socioeconomic development. However, assessing place-based collaborative models in view of their results is challenging due to differing criteria, expectations, and motivations supporting the collaborative partnership framework. This research uses the case study of Montana's Mineral County Challenge, a rural place-based collaborative development project, to make critical inquiries into the long-term efficacy of such approaches. Given that place-based collaborative projects are grounded in geographical traditions, the focus of this assessment is on the role and implications of scale in determining the trajectory of the collaborative process. This is accomplished by evaluating the Mineral County Challenge to (1) recognize the material and non-material outcomes of collaborative development models and, (2) examine the implications and role of scale in catalyzing or hindering the deliberation and realization of these collaborative endeavors. In doing so, the authors emphasize the spatial and temporal constraints including lack of accountability, administrative formalities, and other institutional intricacies which evolved at the federal level to reduce the overall capacity for local and state-level stakeholders to execute long-term project deliverables. In overcoming these barriers, scale must be reconfigured to account for the conflicting conceptual and operational discrepancies that manifest at different levels of stakeholder exchange to derail and disempower place-based collaboration.
KW - Natural resource management
KW - New West
KW - Place-based collaborative management
KW - Politics of scale
KW - Rural development
KW - Rural partnerships
KW - Scale
UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84895753805&partnerID=8YFLogxK
U2 - 10.1016/j.jrurstud.2014.02.004
DO - 10.1016/j.jrurstud.2014.02.004
M3 - Article
AN - SCOPUS:84895753805
SN - 0743-0167
VL - 34
SP - 235
EP - 245
JO - Journal of Rural Studies
JF - Journal of Rural Studies
ER -