Argali abundance in the Afghan pamir using capturerecapture modeling from fecal DNA

Richard B. Harris, John Winnie, Stephen J. Amish, Albano Beja-Pereira, Raquel Godinho, Vânia Costa, Gordon Luikart

Research output: Contribution to journalArticlepeer-review

37 Scopus citations


Estimating population size in a markrecapture framework using DNA obtained from remotely collected genetic samples (e.g., feces) has become common in recent years but rarely has been used for ungulates. Using DNA extracted from fecal pellets, we estimated the size of an argali (Ovis ammon) population that was believed to be isolated from others within the Big Pamir Mountains, Afghanistan, an area where access was difficult and expensive. We used closed-capture models to estimate abundance, and Pradel models to examine closure assumptions, both as implemented in Program MARK. We also made visual counts of argali in the Big Pamirs, allowing comparison of count indices of abundance with modeled estimates. Our model-averaged estimate for female argali in the Big Pamir was 172 (95 CI 117232), which was about 23 higher than our best assessment using uncorrected visual counts. However, markrecapture models suggested that males were not a closed population; thus, we were unable to provide a meaningful estimate of overall population size. Males either suffered much higher mortality than females during the sampling period, or, more likely, males moved in and out of the Big Pamir area. Although information from DNA did not provide a clear overall population estimate, it suggested that the Big Pamir was not isolated from other argali populations, which could not have been confirmed with visual observations alone. Estimating argali population size using markrecapture models and fecal DNA is feasible but may be too expensive for frequent monitoring of large and remote populations. Our study demonstrates the importance of sex identification and separate abundance estimation for each sex, especially if movement ecology differs by sex.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)668-677
Number of pages10
JournalJournal of Wildlife Management
Issue number4
StatePublished - May 2010


  • Abundance estimate
  • Afghanistan
  • Argali
  • Fecal samples
  • Markrecapture
  • Noninvasive sampling
  • Ovis ammon


Dive into the research topics of 'Argali abundance in the Afghan pamir using capturerecapture modeling from fecal DNA'. Together they form a unique fingerprint.

Cite this