TY - JOUR
T1 - Pluralism and naturalism
T2 - Why the proliferation of theories is good for the mind
AU - Preston, Christopher J.
PY - 2005/12
Y1 - 2005/12
N2 - A number of those that have advocated for theoretical pluralism in epistemology suggest that naturalistic arguments from cognitive science can support their case. Yet these theorists have traditionally faced two pressing needs. First, they have needed a cognitive science adequate to the task. Second, they have needed a bridge between whatever scientific account of cognition they favor and the normative claims of a pluralistic epistemology. Both of these challenges are addressed below in an argument for theoretical pluralism that brings together two recent prototype-activation approaches to cognition. The paper dovetails Paul Churchland's neuro-computational approach with George Lakoff and Mark Johnson's image schematic approach, and shows how they mutually support each other in an increasingly persuasive naturalistic case for theoretical pluralism in epistemology.
AB - A number of those that have advocated for theoretical pluralism in epistemology suggest that naturalistic arguments from cognitive science can support their case. Yet these theorists have traditionally faced two pressing needs. First, they have needed a cognitive science adequate to the task. Second, they have needed a bridge between whatever scientific account of cognition they favor and the normative claims of a pluralistic epistemology. Both of these challenges are addressed below in an argument for theoretical pluralism that brings together two recent prototype-activation approaches to cognition. The paper dovetails Paul Churchland's neuro-computational approach with George Lakoff and Mark Johnson's image schematic approach, and shows how they mutually support each other in an increasingly persuasive naturalistic case for theoretical pluralism in epistemology.
KW - Cognitive Science
KW - Epistemology
KW - Naturalism
KW - Patterns and Prototypes
KW - Pluralism
UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=27944480901&partnerID=8YFLogxK
U2 - 10.1080/09515080500355228
DO - 10.1080/09515080500355228
M3 - Article
AN - SCOPUS:27944480901
SN - 0951-5089
VL - 18
SP - 715
EP - 735
JO - Philosophical Psychology
JF - Philosophical Psychology
IS - 6
ER -